Quick answer: There is no single universally accepted test that proves an athlete is ready to return to sport. Instead, clinicians combine five functional test categories — strength and joint stability, dynamic joint stability (proprioception and balance), speed-agility-coordination, plyometrics, and running mechanics — progressing from general activities to sport-specific drills performed under fatigue. Testing begins only once lower-level activity is tolerated without pain, swelling, or discomfort. We run structured return-to-sport testing at our physical therapy clinic in Long Island City.
Functional training, or as I like to call it, sport specific training, involves training and stressing different body tissues in the way they are stressed in the athlete’s specific sport.
Returning to activity, or for athletes returning to sport, after an injury is an important topic in sports performance and rehabilitation. It is a topic that has been studied since athletes first sustained injuries in modern sports and is unlikely to stop being studied anytime soon. This is because there is currently no universally accepted valid and reliable sport specific test used by clinicians in rehabilitation.
In this blog post I will expand on the topic of important general activities that should be trained and tested before returning to sport and highlight the need to also test sport specific activities before returning to sport.
Sport specific activities are important to stress before returning to sport and must be trained, specifically after lower extremity injuries, to safely return to sport, to avoid re-injury, delayed return to sport, or other complications.
In most cases, performance based training and testing can begin after the initial stages of rehabilitation are successfully completed. This means that lower level activities can be tolerated at this stage without swelling, pain, or discomfort before, during and after exercise.
The following functional performance test categories are used by clinicians to evaluate the athlete’s readiness to return safely to sport, as well as to assess lower extremity function. Furthermore these testing categories can give us insight into which skills the athlete needs to correct and improve upon:
- Strength and joint stability: Most often activities that test single leg based skills, such as squatting, to asses general strength and joint stability.
- Joint stability: Dynamic joint stability activities that stress two systems, the proprioception system and the balance system. Proprioception is the ability of a joint to determine position in space and the ability to detect fine movement, while balance is the ability to preserve the center of gravity over the base of support. In most sports, deficiencies in one or both of these systems will result in an injury as unwanted movement will occur.
- Speed, agility and coordination: These are activities that stress the athlete’s ability to develop complex movement patterns in a short period of time, to quickly change direction and cut, and for the athlete’s nervous system and musculoskeletal system to work together to prevent injury while cutting, jumping or pivoting.
- Plyometric: These are activities that stress the athlete’s ability to load, jump and land. They include quick and powerful movements and are used to improve lower extremity dynamic control. In addition, these activities will prepare the neuromuscular system to deal with rapid changes in movement and increased joint forces as needed in various sports.
- Running: Each sport may demand different types of running, sprinting and cutting, therefore the athlete’s running mechanics should be assessed and normalized as needed. In some sports, such as football and lacrosse, activities such as running with several starts and stops should be stressed to mimic the sport’s specific running needs.
Training progressively to achieve harmony between these categories is needed starting with general activities and ending with sport specific activities under fatiguing conditions to account for the demands of the sport.
The Advanced Lower Extremity Sports Assessment (ALESA) is one of the tools that I and many other professionals use to target functional deficits in athletes who want to return to sport after lower extremity injuries. Rather than using this tool as a standard protocol to guide me, I use this assessment tool to gain further insight into the athlete’s quality of movement as it relates to the specific needs of the sport, taking into account all of the aforementioned test categories.
Frequently Asked Questions
When can return-to-sport testing begin after an injury?
Generally after the initial stages of rehabilitation are successfully completed — meaning lower-level activities are tolerated without swelling, pain, or discomfort before, during, and after exercise. Only then does performance-based training and testing make sense.
Is there one test that proves I’m ready to return to sport?
No. There is currently no universally accepted, valid and reliable sport-specific test used across rehabilitation. Clinicians instead use a battery of functional tests plus clinical judgment about movement quality relative to the demands of your specific sport.
What do functional performance tests actually measure?
Five main categories: strength and joint stability (often single-leg tasks), dynamic stability through proprioception and balance, speed, agility and coordination, plyometric ability to load, jump and land, and running mechanics specific to your sport.
Why should athletes be tested under fatigue?
Because sport happens under fatigue. Training and testing should end with sport-specific activities performed in fatiguing conditions to mimic real demands — an athlete who only performs well fresh may still be at risk of re-injury late in games.
What is the ALESA assessment?
The Advanced Lower Extremity Sports Assessment is a tool used to identify functional deficits in athletes returning from lower extremity injuries. Rather than a rigid protocol, it offers insight into movement quality across the key test categories, relative to the sport’s needs.
Leave A Comment